McCoy Roofing

Sara Whitwer on McCoy Roofing

We recently had our roof, gutters, and siding replaced, and the experience exceeded our expectations from start to finish.

The workmanship was excellent; the finished product looks fantastic, and you can tell the quality is there. But what really stood out was how they handled the entire process, especially working directly with our insurance company. They made sure that everything that needed to be replaced was properly documented and included in the claim. That alone removed a huge amount of stress and back-and-forth for us.

Any time we had a question (and we had plenty), they took the time to walk us through it: no runaround, no confusion, just clear, straightforward answers. The crew was friendly, respectful of our home, and incredibly diligent about cleaning up each day. You would never have known such a big project was happening.

Our project manager, Dylan, was fantastic to work with; he was extremely communicative, proactive, and on top of every detail. We always knew what was happening and what to expect next.

Home projects like this can be overwhelming, but McCoy Roofing made it smooth and manageable. We truly can’t say enough good things and would absolutely recommend them.

Joe Birx on McCoy Roofing

We had a small fire on the side of our house which melted the siding, damaged the soffit and the window on one side of the house. I asked my insurance agent if he had any recommendations on who to contact to fix it and he gave me Gabe Fraher's number at McCoy. He was very experienced at dealing with the insurance company and they put all new siding on the house in 2 days at a very reasonable price. Very greatful my insurance agent recommended him and McCoy to get our house fixed. Highly recommend this company!

Mick Reeder on McCoy Roofing

10/10 Gabe & Caleb are AWESOME!!! The whole process was great. The work crew was fast, efficient and left the work site spotless. We LOVE our new siding! We will recommend McCoy to everyone we know!

A Watton on McCoy Roofing

I have had a great experience with Zack and Britton scheduling the roof repair of my home.

10/25/25
I’m updating my review. I advise you, the homeowner, to keep track of the cost (quote) and payments (insurance) given to McCoy. They are horrible on keeping track of payments and what is balanced vs quoted , horrible in collecting methods (your guy that calls to collect final payment calls (is this a spam number with no ID?) and admitting he doesn’t even leave a voicemail. Months go by wandering when they are going to have me square up.
My first time trying to pay they said I owed $8000 from office lady dropping a check off. 2nd time like $3500, 3rd time $2200 which was finally correct after I had to prove it. The office needs an overhaul in payments and keeping up with insurance and what’s truly owed. Guessing isn’t a fair practice. I added my photo of proof to this review.
I am saying the roofers did a great job, but the office is failing the company.

Previous review:
The crew got my roof torn off and replaced all in a single day. The roof looks great!
If you want a GAF certified job done, give them a call.
Another crew came out and did our gutters. Fantastic job.
I recommend McCoy roofing and will definitely use again.

Steve & Jo Coleman on McCoy Roofing

Dillon and Adam were both amazing to work with. Adam came immediately and tarped our roof. Dillon gave a no nonsense approach, talking through the estimate and giving advice on our insurance estimate. He didn’t feel the gutters needed replacing, but felt turbines were important to preserving our new roof. He even kept our holiday lighting hooks for reuse! The installation by Victor was flawless—shingles delivered one day and roof put on the next. Thanks everyone!